Search All Casey Key Real Estate

Casey Key is an eight-mile barrier island off the southwest coast of Florida. Sitting south of Siesta Key, Casey Key is named honoring Captain John Charles Casey. Today, Casey Key hosts prominent spots for fishing and is a big name for island resorts.

Active residents are encouraged to traverse the scenic grounds at the Jim Neville Marine Preserve. Other picturesque spots on the island include Blackburn Point Park and the incredible Nokomis Public Beach, where families and friends can make memories to last a lifetime. Casey Key residents have a selection of restaurants from which to choose, including the Casey Key Fish House and North Jetty Tap and Grill.

Casey Key real estate in western Florida flaunts a lovely array of properties from with to choose, ranging from modern condos to beachfront estates. Waterfront homes for sale in Casey Key are discoverable with contemporary designs and amenities, including private gates, docks, and pools, by which homeowners can watch the sunset over the Gulf of Mexico. Houses for sale in Casey Key featuring lush landscaping can be found in quiet neighborhoods. If you are interested in living in paradise and wish to purchase one of the Casey Key homes for sale in Florida, please contact us today.

Our website features the best Casey Key real estate search for homes, condos, land and foreclosure properties available. It is the only site you will ever need! It is easy-to-use and updated by the official REALTOR®’s database every 15 minutes.

You can save searches, and get daily email alerts of new listings, price changes, sold data, and market reports. Our Interactive Map Search allows you to view properties on a map or refine your search by drawing the boundaries around the area you desire.

Curious about what’s happening in your neighborhood? You can create a custom market report to see what’s active, under contract, and sold in your neighborhood!

Newest Casey Key Homes and Condos for Sale

140 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $2,495,000

COMPLETELY, PROFESSIONALLY AND BEAUTIFULLY UPDATED home on the bay side of North Casey Key. Gorgeous two story vaulted great room with bay side views and large composite...

3 Beds
3.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

3704 Sandspur Lane, Nokomis $899,000

BUILD YOUR DREAM HOUSE on Casey Key ~ one of Sarasota's hidden gems, an isolated and exclusive enclave just off mainland Nokomis. A trip to Sarasota/Nokomis isn't complet...

Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

3704 Sandspur Lane, Nokomis $899,000

Welcome to this furnished Beach House on Casey Key ~ one of Sarasota's hidden gems, an isolated and exclusive enclave just off mainland Nokomis. A trip to Sarasota/Nokomi...

3 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

4028 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $759,900

NEW ROOF 2020! On the 8-mile barrier island of Casey Key, this unique one of a kind two-level contemporary home nestled in a lush tropical environment. The first level f...

3 Beds
2.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

1588 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $10,500,000

On almost three acres, the high-quality construction and impeccable finishes offered throughout this gorgeous beach home create a classic design that is rarely obtainable...

6 Beds
6.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

316 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $8,484,000

When you combine award-winning architecture with an extraordinary Gulf to Bay location the result is pure perfection. Welcome to West Wind, a sprawling modern masterpiece...

6 Beds
7.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

508 S Casey Key Road, Nokomis $2,499,000

CASEY KEY RARE BEACHFRONT HOME. Nearly one acre and 100 feet of frontage on the Gulf of Mexico, along with a private dock on the ICW. This home is move in ready. Beauti...

3 Beds
3.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

12 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $1,200,000

Finally – an affordable house on the waters of Casey Key with amazing views and deeded beach frontage across the street! This home has a new Owens Corning roof that comes...

2 Beds
3 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

1010 Gulf Winds Way, Nokomis $1,449,000

Luxury abounds in this extraordinary custom-built John Cannon waterfront home located in the desirable gated neighborhood of Casey Key Estates. Upon entering the home, yo...

4 Beds
4.5 Baths
Casey Key Estates SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

407 S Casey Key Road, Nokomis $899,000 ▼

Casey Key Bayfront Cottage with Old Florida Charm with beautiful Pecky Cypress wood interior. The main home was built in 1947 and the Master Bedroom / garage building add...

2 Beds
2 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

1027 N Casey Key Road, Osprey $2,695,000 ▼

Cross over a historic swing bridge into the serenity of private North Casey Key. Here, in this tranquil community nestled along a winding island road, is a rare opportuni...

4 Beds
2.5 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34229 Zip Code

2555 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $1,325,000

Build your dream home on this very desirable Casey Key mid-key bay front lot. This magnificent one acre plus lot has 300’ on Sarasota Bay and 225’on the road with an aver...

Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

3250 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $2,950,000 ▼

Welcome to perhaps Casey Key’s most unique Gulf-to-Bay compound. "Brooke’s Landing" is comprised of 3 separate structures & nestled under the cool shade of Old Florida la...

3 Beds
4 Baths
Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

Casey Key Road, Nokomis $795,000 ▼

The perfect setting for your dream home on beautiful Casey Key - a fabulous 8-mile island offering the best in Florida waterfront living and strategically located between...

Casey Key SubDv.
34275 Zip Code

2712 Casey Key Road, Nokomis $1,895,000 ▼

Stunning views of the Intracoastal and private deeded beach access across the street provides this home with an idyllic island setting. One level of living with features ...